GO JSC! This is a lot more energetic of the pieces. Who cares if Jim Lee can churn out a done-looking panel in an hour, this is a much more interesting layout and if finished I'd rather see this one given the complete job over Jim's. Though I like both, naturally. :)
Plus, it was an unfair advantage! Jim Lee's drawn both of those characters before. JSC had to start from scratch. ;)
Sorry, Mr. Lee... But J. Scott wins this one by a hair. The More balanced composition (wolvie left-to-right in the foreground pointing downwards, WW facing left and moving upwards) is what tips the scale.
Lee's is good but Campbell's is better. Lee's Wolverine has a weird expression on his face. Cover his mouth and look at his head and now cover his eyes and look at the mouth area, see what I mean? Campbell's has more punch to it eventhough it is a simpler design. I know that Lee will probably win because of all the kids that worship him but if you study both pics you would pic Campbell.
Ive been looking at these since Friday and now I'm still gonna be 10 minutes late for work cause of it. I gotta give up to both but I'm writing it on Mr. Campbell's side.
10 comments:
Even if there is no sentinel J.S. Campbell have my vote
I gotta agree that the shading and Wolvie are great.
GO JSC! This is a lot more energetic of the pieces. Who cares if Jim Lee can churn out a done-looking panel in an hour, this is a much more interesting layout and if finished I'd rather see this one given the complete job over Jim's. Though I like both, naturally. :)
Plus, it was an unfair advantage! Jim Lee's drawn both of those characters before. JSC had to start from scratch. ;)
Sorry, Mr. Lee... But J. Scott wins this one by a hair. The More balanced composition (wolvie left-to-right in the foreground pointing downwards, WW facing left and moving upwards) is what tips the scale.
Lee's is good but Campbell's is better. Lee's Wolverine has a weird expression on his face. Cover his mouth and look at his head and now cover his eyes and look at the mouth area, see what I mean? Campbell's has more punch to it eventhough it is a simpler design. I know that Lee will probably win because of all the kids that worship him but if you study both pics you would pic Campbell.
Stay off the grid.
tought call, love jim but jsc's wolvie does it for me
I'ma pick this one.
I give my vote to JSC =)
JSC never dissapointed me in the past and today is no exeption !
One vote from france to the master Campbell !
Ive been looking at these since Friday and now I'm still gonna be 10 minutes late for work cause of it. I gotta give up to both but I'm writing it on Mr. Campbell's side.
Post a Comment