Tuesday, July 12, 2005

Iron Chef Challenger Giuseppe Camuncoli

Vote for Cammo's here!

36 comments:

Bruno said...

Both are great, love the shadows on Carlos sketch, but i like the action in Cammo, and the background rendering plus the foreshortening just make the guy pops out, I'm going with Cammo.

DADICUS said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Yano said...

This was a really tough decision this time around. Love the detail and shadows in Carlos' sketch, but there's something that draws me to Giuseppe's. It could be the fact that there is so much action, yet minimal lines are used. This one has my vote!

Tyler Wilken said...

This ones action is awesome!

jasonragle said...

I likes this one mucho.

Salix said...

Now this piece has action! I love the background and the clean lines.

Keith said...

The others said it already: action! The other one has an espionage, Metal Gear Solid thing going for it, but I'd be more interested in a book with this on the cover as opposed to the other drawing.

Grant Gould said...

At first I was gonna vote for Carlos, because his pic grabbed me right away --

But after closer inspection, this one has become my favorite, and it really captures the character. I like the simple, clean style.

I vote for Giuseppe :)

General Chang said...

I'll admit that I'm not really too familiar with the character. I know some of his background but what became of him in the books is something I dont know much about.

So my intended argument of D'Anda's looking too much like a generic secret ops character, probably wont hold much weight.

So based on formal elements, Giuseppe wins my vote. Very dynamic and engaging, nice use of the background and edges of the page.

zuperkrypto said...

this one

RightOnTarget said...

Cammo gets mine. Both I absolutely love, but I just get more of a "Grifter" vibe offa Cammo's.

jorge f. muñoz said...

i love the action, my vote is for Cammo

fotiboss said...

Ovviamente sono ambedue fantastici, però preferisco il Grifter di Cammo per la potenza che esprime!

Giuseppe spero di diventare un fumettista bravo come te!

Grandi!

/Simone

Fogger said...

Carlos!

Oscar said...

As much as I like the detail in Carlos' art, I just have to go with Camuncoli on this one. His clean, yet accented style is perfect for Grifter. Not only do the detailed lines on the gloves, belt and suit look good, I am sure they would really lend themselves over for some nice coloring.

Cammos ... great job on showing us what Grifter is all about!

wilson said...

YEs liked!!! it's much action!!!

nroa9882 said...

Great Stuff

Matteo Ceccotti said...

Not even close ... :)

Cammo gets my vote

patman said...

this one gets my vote. nice clean lines. carlos' version is a character i don't recognize -- just like his version of outsiders ;-).

Tanis of Evermore said...

I love the feel of this one better. It pose and the energy is great on it.

ANMPH said...

Gotta go with this one. Guns blazing, just the way hi would. In the snow no less. Both peices are awesome! I really like the art of the other one more, yet this piece captures who Grifter is more fully in my eyes.

John said...

Good job. You get my vote.

Andreas said...

Cammo gets my nod. Great work, both of you.

Scott E. Amundson said...

As much as I love D'Anda's work (eversince I read the Alan Moore story he illustrated,) I have to go with Guisseppi just because his image captures lotsof vibrant action whereas Carlos' work here is static and not as exciting to this longtime admirer of the gunslinger. Now, how about some western Iron Cheifs?

GTJDorris said...

Holy crap what a hard choice! I gotta give it up for 'Los, but my vote goes to Giuseppe. Just an awesome scene, expertly rendered, just great.

-- Jonathan

daly city steven said...

this pic 'BLAZES' with action! and gets my vote, even though it's way too late...

Vittorio said...

I had to vote Cammo's!!We italians help each other,right...?

monsanto said...

Cammo's got the ammo on this one! I vote for him.

spinkick said...

whoa, these are both fantastic and hard to believe both were done in an hour... I gotta go with Giuseppe's: super tight lines, awesome action, cool background fx... and it made do a double-take on first glance. Carlos' work is unbelievable, just didn't capture the spirit of Grifter in the same way as this one. wow.

Ben Baker said...

I vote for this one, I love his dynamism!

h1cks said...

My vote goes for cammo, his piece has more action, movement..and also i think capture the real Grifter's spirit

John G said...

!!! Cammo Rules.

Edco said...

I'm into the slick lines of Cammo's entry.

stewnami said...

i love both of them, but this one appeals to what i always loved about grifter--full throttle, guns-a-blazing action! more! more!

technogreek said...

fresh & clean!

Balkandude said...

Cammo win!
A big cheers from Munich Bro!
Boris