Thursday, December 08, 2005

Iron Gelatomettista Battle!

Side-by-side! (Don't vote here.)

12 comments:

daveau82 said...

Ooh this one's gonna be a tough choice.

Barak said...

wow, i like them both. But i know who im voting for.

Pinky_Powers said...

I do not know if this is where you cast your votes or not, but I would say Jim Lee came out quite ahead.

Well done to the both of them, I hope they are enjoying a nice beer.

Barak said...

Jim's doesn't remind me of his style at all.

kampilanWil said...

huh? On his piece I could tell it was Jim right away. Mike's would be a bit harder at first glance. But I got my vote and am going with the theme. ;)

DADICUS said...

I'm going to bite through my tongue right now inregards to what I would have said????????????

Juan Ferreyra said...

Jim's by far a better picture, has better design and background, and the characters look better

Barak said...

i disagree with that. Lee's looks like a classic style, its nothing new. Turners brings it hard. Turners is by far better!

Ray Dillon said...

Yeah, Jim's is a finished piece ready for colors and printing on a cover. Michael's is a great sketch.

Gunner143 said...

All I gotta say is 'THANK YOU MR.TURNER AND MR.LEE'
Thank you, thank you, thank you. You guys rock and make me kick myself everyday for not following my dream to become a artist.

Again, let me say 'THANK YOU and Merry Christmas.'

UrbanBarbarian said...

I think it's classic Jim and Turner here! Put on your gloves folks! But don't forget that Jim used to wrestle! Watch out!!!

j.lavo said...

They both are great as expected. But I can point out a few things that don't work.
Jim's moon circle conflicts with the shape of nightcrawlers bag. Instead of being side by side and the same size, the moon can be lowered and larger partially covered by the figure.
Turner's forced perspective on nightcrawlers hand has an odd look because the camera is so far back that the hand just looks giant and out of proportion. Im all about dynamic distortion (Joe Mad!) but that one giant hand isn't working for me.